Sunday, August 15, 2010

Why do people criticize the BCS ';computers'; instead of the BCS voters?

I had heard that the majority of the BCS formula relies upon the voting of people. Why does everyone critcize the computers when it seems the people who vote in the BCS account for way more than the computer variables?



Why do people criticize the BCS ''computers'' instead of the BCS voters?hp



The BCS formula isn't that consistent. The ''VOTES'' are part of the formula.



Why do people criticize the BCS ''computers'' instead of the BCS voters?mcaffee



The computers are much more objective and knowledgable about a team;s strength of schedule.
I think it is more criticizing the system and not the parts of it (i.e. computers and voters). The problem is that there are too many teams that are too close together and we will never know who is better until they play eachother!
The AP is no longer a part of the BCS. That is why the Harris Poll was brought in.



The reason I hate the computers is because they vote but can't ''watch'' the game. So they don't know if it is a rivalry or see injuries or anything like that.
the computers were orginally 2/3rds of the vote I believe. So since they were so important at the start people keep blaming them.
Yeah they are factored. But look at all of the years, we have had split titles. Because the BCS and the AP had different #1 and #2. So the computers still have their say.
the strength of schedule issue is not the all important factor that the bcs uses it as. there have been several games this season that teams have played particular games waaaaayyy out of their SoS. i think the bcs was brought in for a good reason, but it cannot account for the efforts in games affected by rivalry, weather, extraordinary play against a heavily favored opponent and such. what about comebacks? should a team be penalized for putting up a fight to win at the end instead of giving up and getting a loss? if they are to use computers to analyize rankings, why not put a few factors into the computations that give more game flavor to the ending results since there is likely to never be a playoff tournament. it would be crazy to try to compare all the teams that play in one year with schedules set so far in advance of play and relying on the SoS, that when it was set might have been a totally different picture than three years later when the game plays out.



  • acrylic nails gel nails
  • clear my labtop
  • No comments:

    Post a Comment